Saturday, January 21, 2006

Visions of Liberty, edited by Martin Greenberg and Mark Tier

Visions of Liberty, edited by Martin Greenberg and Mark Tier

This was one of the most disappointing collection of short stories I’ve read in a long time. Nine tales of a future without government, none of them interesting. Every author takes the same approach: that utopia can be achieved when bureaucracy is removed. No courts or laws exist, and society functions flawlessly. Poppycock! We are a venal and selfish civilization and need some form of arbitration. I believe in limited government, but not anarchy. While the idea of a world run on honor and ethics is appealing, I’m too cynical to believe it is possible and the authors didn’t present any believable alternatives.

First Sentence (from the introduction):
Imagine we’re on a plane; we’ve crossed an ocean, we’ve landed; we’re taxiing up to the gate.

No comments:

Search This Blog